Reviewing Castle AI Pick Reports and Champion Feature Requests

I’ve decided to open up the Castle AI Pick Report pages and the Feature Voting pages for everyone to view. It will still only be possible for Champions to comment and vote on these items but I see no reason why everyone shouldn’t be able to see what is going on.

Today I’d like to take a bit of a look at what people have been writing on those pages and provide my own thoughts. So to start off with let’s address a few common themes in Castle AI Pick Reports. You can view these here:

http://www.cubetutor.com/championcentral/castleai/pickdecisionreports

Next up I’d like to provide some feedback on some of the more popular Feature Requests. You can view these here.

http://www.cubetutor.com/championcentral/features/vote

One thing I would like to say here is please don’t be afraid to downvote/disagree. Votes are completely anonymous and it really helps me to gauge the popularity of a particular feature request.

  • See Picks after Saving Deck – http://www.cubetutor.com/championcentral/features/feature/3. I would love to be able to do this, the only problem is the quantity of data. For each draft we’d need to store all of the cards that each bot picked and passed along with how each of those cards very evaluated by the AI and the detected Strategy for each pick. It’s fine to keep all of this “in memory” to show it during the draft but making it available later would require saving a lot of information. It’s possible that I could solve this using a different storage system, like a NoSQL data store. Like every feature request it’s a cost-benefit thing and I really need to gauge how important this would be for the community before committing to it.
  • Working “Remember Me” functionhttp://www.cubetutor.com/championcentral/features/feature/6 It was my view that the Remember Me check box worked perfectly as long as you only used it on one device (this isn’t ideal I know). However you guys are telling me that it’s not always working for you even on one device so I totally intend to go back to this feature and make it work properly. For anyone in the Champion community, I’d really appreciate hearing about your experience using the feature in the comments on that page.
  • Group Rotisserie Draft – http://www.cubetutor.com/championcentral/features/feature/16. The difficulty I have is that (for the time being at least) I must avoid anything that could be considered Multi Player. It’s a delicate situation but suffice to say anything that could theoretically compete with Magic Online is something that I will be avoiding. Now I’m completely aware that MTGO does not offer a Rotisserie draft function (heck you can’t even draft a personal cube on there yet) but if they were to turn around tomorrow and decide that’s what they wanted to do then I don’t want to be in a position where Cube Tutor could be taking away business from them. I’m also completely aware that other sites out there may offer things like this (either now or in the near future) but I can’t speak for them, all I can do is tell you guys where I’m coming from.
  • Simulated Draftshttp://www.cubetutor.com/championcentral/features/feature/7. This is a nice idea and I could totally see it working. I’d have to figure out the best way of representing a simulated draft visually during the drafting process itself which may take some time to complete.
  • Solitaire Mode – http://www.cubetutor.com/championcentral/features/feature/17. This comes back to the same principle that I must avoid features which may be considered to compete with Magic Online. I know that a solitaire system may not seem like much but it is a feature that could take us down a path of simulating the process of playing a game of Magic the Gathering. Cube Tutor is all about management and testing, not playing. Whilst I can totally see how Solitaire mode could help you test your cube I’m afraid it’s just a step too far, for now at least. However I do believe that a Sample Hand Generator is a reasonable request. I’m completely aware that other sites out there may offer things like this (either now or in the near future) but I can’t speak for them, all I can do is tell you guys where I’m coming from.
  • Most Drafted Cardshttp://www.cubetutor.com/championcentral/features/feature/9. This is a feature that has been requested a lot so I will look at it for a release very soon!
  • Card Quality should be Editable for AI purposeshttp://www.cubetutor.com/championcentral/features/feature/15. The AI builds a per cube Pick Order based on the global Cube Tutor pick order. A few people have mentioned that the AI seems to rank strong cards quite low for Quality. Whilst the measure of quality is cube-specific I can still understand that players may wish to configure this quality scoring for particular cards. I’ve marked this one as Pending Fix and will look to complete it in an upcoming release.
  • Mass Edits to Lists – http://www.cubetutor.com/championcentral/features/feature/14. This one could be a little tricky from a User Interface perspective but I can completely understand why people want it. The Edit List page could do with a small overhaul to improve performance so, based on the popularity of this request I will probably tackle this piece of work when I get on to that.
  • Mobile Friendliness http://www.cubetutor.com/championcentral/features/feature/20. I’m very aware of how difficult it can be to use parts of Cube Tutor on a mobile device. It’s a big piece of work but if I am afforded the time to do so by the community and the Patreon Campaign, it’s certainly something that is high on my personal To Do list for Cube Tutor.
  • Sort/Filtering by Artisthttp://www.cubetutor.com/championcentral/features/feature/12. This is a nice idea. Currently the Cube Tutor database does not contain Artist information for each card, and it is relatively non-trivial for me to add it. However, like anything I will judge this request on it’s popularity in the Champion community.

Obviously there are a lot more feature requests to go through and I am looking at them all so if your item hasn’t been mentioned here then it may well come up in a future blog post.

Thanks for reading and remember even if you don’t have a feature to propose, please do check out what other people are suggesting and weigh in with your own opinions. Votes are anonymous and it really helps me out to know what you guys are thinking!

Until next time,

– Ben

Advertisements

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: